Argisol - analiza comparativa beton, pompa beton, armaturi, transport

Studiind ,, ANALIZA COMPARATIVA ,, rezulta alte avantaje nete ale sistemului Argisol

de Emil Valeanu la categoria Recenzie

Publicat la 04.05.2010 | 964 vizualizări | 0 comentarii

ANALIZA COMPARATIVA CONSUM BETON  
                                                PACHET T2
 
 
       ARTICOL /  LUCRARE                                   PRIMARIE          DISPENSAR        POLITIE
                 Suprafata DESFASURAT                   SD = 976 MP  SD = 590 MP        SD=278 MP
 
VARIANTA ARGISOL
 
VOLUM BETON FUNDATIE            112 MC                         85 MC                           60 MC
VOLUM BETON PERETI                152 MC                         120 MC                         49 MC
VOLUM BETON PLANSEE             77 MC                           33 MC                           14 MC
VOLUM BETON SCARA                10 MV                           12 MC                           6 MC
 
TOTAL BETON PCONST               239 MC                         165 MC                         69 MC
 
TOTAL BETON TOTAL                 351 MC                         250 MC                         129 MC                        
INDICII CONSUM - ARGISOL
 
I1 = Vbet str/ Sd                0,243                0,279                0,244
 
I2 = Vbet tot/ Sd                0,358               0,423               0,460
 
VARIANTA CLASICA
 
VOLUM BETON FUNDATIE                112                               125                               80
VOL BET ELEVATII SUBS                     30                                 120                               20
VOL BET PLACA UMPLUT                   28                                 49                                 23
VOL BET STALPI SUBS                        11,5                              -                                   6
VOL BET PLACA SUBS                         14                                 40                                 -
VOL BET STALPI STRUCT                    22                                 9                                  -
VOL BET CENT+ GRINZI                      42                                 8                                  14
VOL BET SCARA + PLACA                97                                 40                                 22
 
VOL TOTAL BETON STRUCT        356,5 MC                       391 MC                         165 MC
 
INDICI CONSUM  - CLASIC
 
I3 = Vbet tot struct/Sd                       0,365                                   0,662                           0,593
 
CONCLUZIE – Comparand consumul mediu de volum de beton total, aferenta suprafetei desfasurate – I2 = 0,413 mc/mp in cazul Argisol cu – I3 = 0,541 MC/MP – in cazul structurii clasice, Argisol-ul castiga cu o reducere de 31% a cantitatii de beton/ mp desfasurat investitie. Daca mai adaugam si volumul de mortar aferent zidariei procentul creste la aproximativ 50%. Vom analiza acest lucru cand analizam consumurile de elemente de zidarie.
 
 
 
                                        Expert Tehic Argisol RO
 
                                                Ing Valaenu Emil
 
 
INDICI DE CONSUM POMPA DE BETON
 
- prima cifra = nr de deplasari APB
- a doua cifra = nr de ore consummate pentru turnare betonului la o capacitate de 8 mc/ora beton turnat
 
VARIANTA ARGISOL
 
 
APB Argisol – DEPL/ORE     7 / 42                6 / 24                4 / 17
                -   ORE/ SD       0,043                0,040                0,060
 
VARIANTA CLASIC
 
 
APB Clasic  - DEPL/ORE       8 / 57                7 / 51                6 / 27
                - ORE / SD        0,058                0,086                0,097
 
 
CONCLUZIE :
 
-         Comparand numarul de deplasari ale pompei de beton, rezulta un avantaj de aproximativ 25% in favoarea sistemului Argisol.
-         Comparand necesarul de ore de turnare beton rezulta un avantaj in favoarea sistemului Argisol de aproximativ 42%
 
                                                                                                    Expert tehic Argisol RO
                                                                                                            Ing Valeanu Emil



 
          ANALIZA COMPARATIVA  A CONSUMULUI DE
                                      ARMATURI SI PLASE SUDATE
 
               ARTICOL LUCRARE                         PRIMARIE         DISPENSAR         POLITIE
              SD                                                     SD = 976 MP       SD = 590 MP        SD = 278MP
 
 
 
VARIANTA ARGISOL
 
ARMATURI FUND                 2700 KG                       4200 KG                                   1400 KG
ARMATURI STRUCT             21500 KG                     13000 KG                                 6200 KG
PLASA SUD STRUCT            1700 KG                     600 KG                                     300 KG
ARMATURI SCARI                    300 KG                     200 KG                                     150 KG
 
 
 
TOT ARM STR                         26200 KG                 18000 KG                                   8050 KG
 
IND I 4 = Tot/Sd                         26,84 KG/MP          30,5KG/MP                               28,9kg/mp
 
 
VARIANTA CLASICA
 
ARMATURA FUND           2700 KG                 4200 KG                                 1400 KG
ARM DIAFR SUBS             300                         9000                                          900
ARM PL UMPLUT              1700                       3800                                         1100
ARM ST SUBS                   1800                         -                                               1400
ARM GR+CENT SUBS       2100                        -                                                  -
ARM PL SUBSOL               1400                      7700                                             -
 
ARM ST STRUCTURA      7800                       1300                                             -
ARM GR+ CENTURI          10.000                    2100                                         1700
ARM SC + PLACA             9800                       4000                                          8900
 
 
 
TOT ARM STR                    37600 KG             32100 KG                           8900KG
 
IND I4 = Tot/Sd                  38,52 kh/mp         54,4 kg/mp                            32kg/mp
 
CONCLUZIE : comparand consumul mediu armatura / mp desf de 28,74 kg/mp in cazul Argisol cu 41,64 kg/mp cat este in cazul sistemului clasic, rezulta o economie de aproximativ 44% in favoarea  sistemu-lui Argisol.
 
                                                               Expert tehnic Argisol RO – ing Valeanu Emil 



 
            13.04.2010


               ANALIZA ECONOMICA COMPARATIVA TRANSPORT SI     MANIPULARI     DE  MATERIALE  IN SISTEM CLASIC/ ARGISOL
                                                        PACHET DE INVESTITII : T1, T2, T3.
 
        PACHET T1 – PRIMARIE = 796 mp
 
                SISTEM CLASIC                                  ARGISOL
 
-         zidarii : 1100mp>330mc>600To>30 curse
-         plansee: 950mp>95To>5 curse                       } 14To> 6 curse
 
- beton+mort : 290mc>725To>33 curse     } 241mc>600To>         27 c
 
 
TOTAL T1;             1420To > 68 curse                614To > 33 curse
 
 
     PACHET T2 : Primarie, Politie, Dispensar = 1844 mp
 
              SISTEM CLASIC                                               ARGISOL
 
TOTAL T2               2133 To > 108 curse             507To > 63 curse
 
 
 
     PACHET T3 – Total 14 obiective = 7490 mp
 
              SISTEM CLASIC                                               ARGISOL
 
TOTAL T3      8772 To > 438 curse                    2057 To > 259 curse
 
CONCLUZIE:
Analizand comparativ cifrele ( TO transportate si numar de curse ) rezulta un avantaj net, in favoarea sistemului Argisol
 
                            Expert Tehnic Argisol : ing Valeanu Emil